• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Air compressors
  • Lawn Mowers
  • Chainsaws
  • Welding
  • Water
    • Water Filters
    • Water Softeners
    • Water Heaters

Kyle's Garage

Kyle's Garage

The pros and cons of hot water recirculating pump systems

By Kyle's Team

pros and cons of hot water recirculating pump

How long do you spend waiting for hot water to take a shower? For the average homeowner, the answer is at least two minutes. That’s a lot of time to spend waiting and a lot of water to waste. But there might be a way to end both these problems. Consider the pros and cons of hot water recirculating pump. A device like that might be the right fit for you.

Table of Contents

  • Reasons You May Need A Hot Water Recirculation Pump
  • Hot Water Recirculation System How Does It Work?
  • Types Of Recirculation Pump Systems.
    • Open system
    • Dedicated return/Bypass Valve
    • Tankless System
  • Under Sink Hot Water Circulator
  • Pros And Cons Of Recirculation Pump Systems
    • Get Hot Water Without The Wait
    • Conserves Water
    • Saves Money
    • Saves Time
    • Sensors
  • Cons Of Recirculation Pump Systems
    • Cost
    • Noise
    • Uses A lot Of Energy
    • Cold Water Return
    • Heat Loss
    • Needs To Be Plugged In
  • Conclusion- Is A Hot Water Recirculating Pump Worth It?

Reasons You May Need A Hot Water Recirculation Pump

Hot water boiler Boiler room with a heating system

Do you know that, on average, a shower takes about ten gallons of water? But you also use 2.5 gallons just waiting for hot water to get to the water outlet you want to use. For an average-sized family, this number translates to about 10,000 gallons a year.

The reason for that wastage is because you have to wait for the water heater to heat up. Then you also have to wait for that heated water to make its way through your plumbing system.

In short, the cold water has to leave your taps first. Then the heated water has to travel a distance to get your water out. If your home is on the grander side, that distance and wait are even longer.

And when you turn the tap off again, the hot water you were using stays in your plumbing system. It doesn’t make its way back to the heater. As time passes, it becomes cold.

The cycle begins again when next you need hot water.

A recirculation pump may be just what you need. Before we dive into the hot water recirculating pump pros and cons let’s take a look at:

    • What recirculation pumps are

And

    • How recirculation pumps work

From time to time, we may refer to recirculation pumps as recirculation systems. We will also use the term recirculation loop. These words mean the same thing.

Hot Water Recirculation System How Does It Work?

The hot water recirculation system design allows you to add this device to:

      • Your tank water heater
      • Your tankless water heater

There are different types and ways to install them, but we won’t get into the details here. They all do the same thing.

They reroute the hot water in your plumbing system, which you have not used, back to the water heater.

Types Of Recirculation Pump Systems.

Blue electric high pressure water pump isolated on white

There are three types of recirculation pump systems.

Open system

These hot water circulation loop systems are for water heating tanks. They fit at the top of water heaters and do not need a recirculation line.

Dedicated return/Bypass Valve

This system is also for water heating tanks. They fit at the bottom of water heaters, but they need a recirculation line. Older homes have recirculation lines. If you do not have one, you cannot use this system unless you put in one. Redoing your entire plumbing system will cost a pretty penny. They are also the most costly to install.

Tankless System

Recirculation pumps do not fit well with tankless systems. That’s because for them to do the job you want them to, your heater can never switch off. Doing so may kill your tankless system before its time. You may have better luck using a buffer with your tankless than with a recirculation pump.

Under Sink Hot Water Circulator

Under-sink hot water circulator systems deliver rapid hot water to water outlets. Where other hot water loop systems fit on your water heater, these fit under the sink. But you must install them at the fixture that has the most space between it and the water heater.

This type of device is the most energy-efficient.

Pros And Cons Of Recirculation Pump Systems

Pump waterpump

Let’s deal with the pros first.

Get Hot Water Without The Wait

It carries hot water quickly to all water outlets around the house. Instead of waiting long minutes, you only have to wait a few seconds for your hot water delivery.

Conserves Water

Water is a vital resource, and there is less and less of it to go around. Since your recirculation pump brings hot water to you almost right away, you don’t have to flush out the cold.

Saves Money

Waiting for hot water to comes through the faucet is the same as flushing money down the drain. You have to pay the utility company for that cold water you drained away and the energy your water heater burns. It might not seem like much, but over the months and years, that money adds up. By the end of twelve months, you will pay extra to the utility company for water you did not even use.

That money can stay in your pocket if you have this type of hot water loop system.

Saves Time

Calculate the number of minutes you spend a year waiting for hot water to take a shower for the year. It adds up to a few hours. That’s a lot of time. But with a Recirculation pump, you can cut that waiting period down to zero.

Sensors

These pumps come with sensors. Once your water reaches the temperature you set it to, the pump switches of. This feature will save on energy use.

Almost zero Maintenance

Cons Of Recirculation Pump Systems

Cost

The main challenge to setting up your recirculation pump system is the startup cost. No matter what the type, these systems cost a lot and are even more expensive to install. And each one comes with its own limitations. We’ll take a look at these types in a bit.

Noise

Some pumps are loud, especially as they age.

Uses A lot Of Energy

Although under the sink systems are the most efficient, they still use a lot of energy. That kind of energy use can affect your utility bills and not in a way that you like. If you decide to go for a hot water circulation loop system, installing a timer might be a good idea. Some pumps come with timers.

Cold Water Return

To switch from hot water to cold, you need a hot water recirculating pump with return line installed. If you do not have that, you have to wait a few minutes to get cold water. The water may stay lukewarm for a while.

Unless you have that recirculation line, there is nothing you can do about it.

Heat Loss

Without proper insulation, heat will escape from the hot water recirculation line. You may have to get your pipes inspected and fixed before installing this device. Doing so is an extra cost.

Needs To Be Plugged In

These systems work on electricity. There must be an outlet near the installation point.

Conclusion- Is A Hot Water Recirculating Pump Worth It?

Water recirculation pumps are not an exact science when it comes to pros and cons. Some factors may make using a in one area more beneficial than using it in another. My advice to homeowners is doing extensive research before committing.

Remember, these systems are costly to buy and install. You should not spend that money if you are not going to gain anything from it.

Persons who live in places where the price of water and energy is high stand to gain the most out of these systems.

Filed Under: Water heaters

Primary Sidebar

Suggested posts

    are upper and lower water heater elements the same
  • Are upper and lower water heater elements the same?
  • can cpvc be connected directly to electric water heater
  • Can cpvc be connected directly to electric water heater?
  • Heating It Up: How a Boiler Operates
  • Heating It Up: How a Boiler Operates
  • can a hot water heater survive a flood
  • Can a hot water heater survive a flood?
  • element stuck
  • What to do if you got your Water Heater Element Stuck
  • how to check water heater element
  • How To Check Water Heater Element Units And Replace Them
  • Close up of Gas water heater in the kitchen
  • Does a gas water heater need electricity?
  • water heater powered anode rod
  • Homeowners guide: Powered Anode Rod vs sacrificial anode rod
  • thermopile voltage low
  • Is your Thermopile Voltage Low?
  • Outdoor Propane Tankless Water Heater
  • The pros and cons of an outdoor propane tankless water heater

More information about water heaters

Categories

  • Air Compressors
  • Blog
  • Buying Guides
  • Chainsaws
  • Generators
  • How-Tos
  • Lawn Mowers
  • Reviews
  • Roof
  • Snow blowers
  • Water
    • Water filters
    • Water heaters
    • Water softeners
  • Welding

Footer

About

Kylesgarage.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Additionally, kylesgarage.com participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links.

Top Posts

Your Ultimate 2020 Mini Split Buying Guide

Your Ultimate 2021 Mini Split Buying Guide

Best Cordless Impact Wrench

Best Cordless Impact Wrench

Best Small Dehumidifier 2021

Best Small Dehumidifier 2021

More Buying Guides

Menu

  • Home
  • Buying Guides
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclosure
  • Contact Us

Kyle's Garage Copyright © 2023 · All rights reserved.